April 13, 2026

Will EVs Surge Amid Iran Oil Shocks?

Will EVs Surge Amid Iran Oil Shocks?
Political Climate
Will EVs Surge Amid Iran Oil Shocks?

Gas prices are spiking as the Iran war disrupts global oil markets — so will this be the moment that finally supercharges EV adoption in the U.S.?

This week on Political Climate, we explore how past energy shocks have driven policy shifts aimed at greater energy diversification — and whether history is repeating itself, only with new stakes.

Avery Ash, CEO of Securing America's Future Energy (SAFE), joins the show to discuss how geopolitics, consumer behavior, and technological advancements are colliding at a pivotal moment.

Does the U.S. need a more strategic, policy-driven approach to energy security in an era of rising conflict and global competition?

Political Climate is presented by ClearPath, one of the most influential organizations working to advance American energy innovation while reducing global emissions.

Subscribe to catch all of our latest episodes! And head on over to ⁠politicalclimatepodcast.com⁠ to sign up for our soon returning newsletter.

Julia (00:00.898)
Brandon, did you make it to Indy for the final four? How about your hangover?

Brandon (00:03.832)
I did. Neil provided some great tips. He was basically like my travel agent for the trip and all the recommendations were fantastic. Even though my team lost on Saturday, I had a great weekend with my college buddies and super cool to be there.

Julia (00:22.456)
I feel like I won March Madness because I knew nothing about March Madness and then I ended up interviewing Shane Battier, which then I got a lot of like props for, which you know, I'm cool now guys in the sports ball world.

Neil (00:34.914)
Honestly, that episode that we recorded was perfectly timed because I think at the, five years from now, people won't remember that Michigan won the national championship. They'll remember that Duke Connecticut game. And so I think we have the perfect content, the perfect guest for the tournament.

Julia (00:48.238)
Sorry, Michigan.

Brandon (00:49.102)
Everybody was talking about it in Indianapolis, know, political climate was.

Julia (00:53.294)
Sure.

Julia (01:01.742)
Welcome back to Political Climate brought to you with support from ClearPath. I'm your host, Julia Pyper, and by day I'm Vice President of Public Affairs at GoodLeap. You may be hearing the phrase pain at the pump a whole lot lately as the war in Iran, now in its sixth week, continues to trigger historical global oil market disruptions. In fact, it's some of the biggest supply disruptions in the history of the global oil market, according to experts.

As we record this, the US and Iran have agreed to a two-week ceasefire, with Iran allowing safe passage for marine traffic through the Strait of Hormuz, but the conflict has not been fully resolved. And even if it is, energy sector impacts could linger for months or even years. Meanwhile, as US consumers contend with high gas prices, interest in electric vehicles has spiked. But whether that interest will translate into real-world purchases remains unclear. EV sales in the US have stalled around 10 % over the last couple of years. This dip could prove to be a speed bump.

or signal a tougher road ahead for vehicle electrification and the promise of economic opportunity that comes with it. Will pain at the pump provide the jump that the EV market needs to accelerate? In this episode, energy security meets consumer choice, where geopolitics, gas prices, economic competitiveness, and the future of driving all collide. That's all coming up on Political Climate.

Julia (02:17.4)
As always, I'm joined by Brandon Hurlbut, who served as Chief of Staff in President Obama's Energy Department and went on to found Boundary Stone Partners and Overture VC. Brandon, how are you doing today?

Brandon (02:26.318)
Pretty good. We had another election last night, this time in Georgia, special election to replace Marjorie Taylor Greene. And there was a 25 point swing in that district, Julia, towards the Democrats. The Democrats didn't win, but it was a plus 37 Trump district and the Republican only won by 12.

Julia (02:42.124)
And that was just a complete Marjorie Taylor Greene's terms. So these guys will face off again this fall. Right. So interesting. A lot of money went into that race. One to watch.

We were also watching the news, of course, as this deadline approached the President Trump had set. We're recording this on Wednesday, April 8th. Definitely a timely episode this time around. Of course, we also have Neil Chatterjee on the line. He served as energy advisor to Senator Mitch McConnell and is chairman of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission under President Trump's first term. He is now chief government affairs officer at Palmetto, a clean tech developer. How you feeling over there in the DMV, Neil?

Neil (03:18.318)
Wild times, wild news cycle. I know the liberal media wants to say yesterday was TACO Tuesday again, but look, the guy gets results. We've got a ceasefire. Hopefully we don't wind up in World War III as

Julia (03:30.295)
result.

These are tense times. got to say as a mom of two little kids, it's a little a little stress inducing. I'm sure it is for everybody. And of course, there's a lot to unpack because we're all feeling it. Whether or not you're following the news, you're going to feel the knock on effects of this conflict, as we've talked about in our first episode of the season. But it's not going away. Even if we achieve some level of peace here, we'll unpack this in our interview. But we could see some lasting impacts across energy markets. And of course, that is what we're going to dig into today, as well as dynamics for the EV sector as a result. So with that, I'm

excited to welcome to the show our guest Avery Ash, CEO of Securing America's Future Energy or SAFE. It's a nonpartisan organization committed to transportation, energy and supply chain policies that advance the economic and national security of the United States and its global allies. Avery stepped into the CEO role just a few months ago after serving as SAFE's senior vice president of government affairs, where he also led the Coalition for Reimagined Mobility. Prior to SAFE, he was director of federal relations at the American Automobile Association, AAA, and the transportation analytics company, INRIX.

Full disclosure, I met Avery over a decade ago, maybe geez, closer to 15 years ago when I was a reporter working at E &E News in Washington, D.C. So it's kind of like the good old days returned, Avery, but maybe a little higher stakes in our careers and the state of the world. How you doing?

Avery (04:44.172)
I'm doing well. were talking about $4 gallon of gasoline then and here we are again talking about $4 gallon gasoline.

Julia (04:50.03)
It's Groundhog Day all over again.

I thought you'd be the perfect guest as we continue to wrestle with what the current Middle East conflict and this moment in time mean more broadly for energy security, but also the related impacts for clean tech and climate and the US economy and frankly, global economy writ large. It's something that we talked about on the show even in the last couple episodes, but you're a pro, you're the expert here and we're hoping you can help us flesh out really what this moment means. So I first have to note though, you are not wearing the signature yellow tie that I've seen in every headshot of you lately, so.

What's going on? Rebrand?

Avery (05:22.658)
I know I had some feedback. really needed to change things up a little bit. After returning to DC four years ago from the startup world, I shifted away from Patagonias and button downs and jeans back to suits, but trying to find that happy medium.

Neil (05:35.896)
went the other way. went from almost exclusively wearing shirts and ties to now I just wear sweatshirts.

Julia (05:40.846)
All right, let's get serious here. So SAFE, Securing America's Future Energy, has been focused on energy security for over two decades. And I understand the organization actually conducted a war game years ago. They looked at the prolonged closure of the Strait of Hormuz and what the impacts would be. And this is back in 2007. I'm guessing the disruption we're seeing today in global energy markets then is not entirely surprising. But Avery, maybe start with what were the implications that might have been expected and how are we actually seeing that play out in the real world?

Avery (06:09.966)
Absolutely, Julia. Thank you guys for having me. I mentioned it's a little bit deja vu for me personally right now, coming from my role at AAA as their oil and gas price analyst for half dozen years starting in 2010, talking about things like the Arab Spring and the Strait of Hormuz and the implications on consumers for prices at the pump and global oil prices. For safe, that deja vu goes back even further.

Safe was founded in 2005 and in 2006 and 2007, we launched what we called our oil shock waves. So these were tabletop exercises to model out with senior officials playing the role of senior government stakeholders, as well as oil executives and others. What would happen if, and one of those ifs was what would happen if there were a prolonged closure to the Strait of Hormuz?

due to a conflict with Iran. And we had some pretty interesting implications. Stop me if you've heard any of these talked about in the last couple of weeks. In that exercise, we saw oil prices rising to $160 a barrel. We're not there yet. We saw gas prices rising to 550 a gallon. It's the national average. We saw the US with double-digit unemployment rates and inflation and a host of other geopolitical challenges emerging, including for that exercise, China invading Taiwan.

The takeaway from every participant that took part in this exercise was that once you're in a crisis, it is too late to pull near-term levers to get yourself out of it. And to a person, they found themselves with their kind of wrap-up takeaways wishing that previous administrations and Congresses had done more to address the problem. We're now flash forward 20 years later, and we're seeing this sort of a hypothetical scenario play out in real time.

We're seeing a lot of the same types of impacts grabbing national headlines. And then think there's a very interesting conversation though around where we have seen those impacts be maybe even somewhat muted with what we would have expected 20 years ago and why.

Avery (08:07.362)
But certainly these spikes, when you're a consumer going to fill up your gas tank or you're a business who's looking at how higher pump prices feed into your profits, this is a very real challenge people are expecting. And we're now starting to see these conversations emerging as we have historically when price spikes take hold around what can we do short term, medium term and long term.

Brandon (08:28.394)
Avery, my understanding is that once you shut down some of the production in the Middle East, it takes much longer than anyone really knows to get it back going again. And so that's why you have some of these CEOs from United and whatnot saying they're expecting 150 to $175 barrel oil for like months to maybe through next year. But the price of oil is down today and the stock market's up. So how do you explain that mismatch?

Avery (08:53.614)
There's a lot of different factors to go into play there. One of the things I learned early on in my oil price analyst days was that a supply chain shock anywhere impacts prices everywhere. We're certainly seeing that today. What has shifted from when we did this exercise 20 years ago or back in the 70s during the Iran oil embargo is that the US has really shifted in its role in the global production and consumption stage.

We have gone from being a net importer of crude oil to a net exporter. That somewhat insulates us from these sorts of global price spikes. Correct, but the US's ability to influence that global price by virtue of having produced more and across the board fuel efficiency gains we've seen globally.

Brandon (09:28.526)
But it's a global price, right?

Avery (09:39.458)
really kind of changed some of that calculus. You we spent a lot of time early days at SAFE talking about the risks of a global cartel like OPEC to be able to drive oil prices higher with press release. We've seen a lot less discussion of OPEC's ability to influence markets. And that's a large part because we've seen such an increase in production globally from other Western sources, as well as a diversification away from a petro-state status to an electrostate status for many countries around the

While this is where we stand today, I think the one thing I would underscore is this is an incredibly volatile situation. And this is the sort of environment when you think through supply chains, global oil markets in particular, where there is a lot more to develop here. The story has really not yet completely be written. We're going to find that out over the coming months. I think the expectation is that the impact that consumers and businesses are facing.

are likely to be measured in months, not weeks. There's a lot more to be understood here and I expect will develop in the days ahead.

Julia (10:39.698)
Do people know what energy security means? What does that mean to people when they hear that term? I think it's easy to start to throw it around, but is this a unique moment for energy security? Is it understood?

Avery (10:49.688)
think it requires some definition, particularly at a national and a policymaker level. And SAFE spent 20 years trying to explain what energy security is, why it matters, how it interfaces with national security, and what we can do about it. I actually think at an individual level, at a constituent or a voter or energy consumer level, people really do get what energy security is. They may not call it that.

And that's the angst that comes with how am I going to plan for my year ahead for the sorts of energy access and the energy prices that are going to drive my personal budget. Americans are very used to dealing with those sorts of kitchen table energy security conversations. I think the bigger challenge is how does that ladder up to a national conversation about energy security that allows policymakers to think about this in a pragmatic, holistic way that will actually help us to solve a national problem?

which will carry down to an individual level of people being able to be more confident in the power they need to live their lives.

Brandon (11:45.922)
I just want to add one point there and let others jump in. I think this is highly relevant for the midterm elections because I think a lot of what Democrats will be saying is this is what Trump promised and this is how he broke that promise. And one of the promises that was made was drill baby drill. Drill baby drill will be energy independent and you'll be safe. And we're producing more oil than ever and exporting it. And yet within 30 days, the price of gasoline went up a dollar per gallon.

And so drill baby drill does not protect you. That's, think, just another promise that was not kept.

Neil (12:18.222)
Yeah, I just want to push back on Brandon a little bit. You, Beijing Brandon. Avery, in my view, while certainly, you know, there might be some issues around drill baby drill and the president's promises and the price of the pump, I do think Americans recognize there are broader strategic objectives here. I would think that this situation in Iran, the war there has far greater implications for China's fuel dependence in their economy than the US. Aren't they the big losers?

Avery (12:47.886)
It's a very real question to be asked right now, right? We spend at SAFE a lot of time viewing energy security as a national security consideration. And in the context of China, it is certainly true that as an oil producer, well, they do produce, it's not as significant as US production. They have spent the last several decades though transitioning away from their oil dependency and

hell-bent on building as much electrical generation as they possibly could. There's kind of a number of different reasons for that, both from the view that those sorts of technologies would be driving the 21st century economic growth, but there's also a very self-centered perspective there, too, of...

diversifying away from fuel sources that you're not a producer of towards domestic sources that you can control and don't have an impact on your national security when there is a supply disruption, whether that be from a natural disaster or because of a global adversary weaponizing your supply chain vulnerabilities against you.

Julia (13:47.054)
Right. And just to level set, a fifth of global oil and gas travels through the Strait of Hormuz. Since the conflict started, there have been strikes on energy infrastructure sites. So that includes within Iran, most recently on Kharg Island, but also in other countries in the region. know, Saudi, Qatari, UAE sites have also been hit. And so that's what Brandon's referring to about broader disruption that could linger on here. But of course, to China's point, and we've talked about this on the show, they've stockpiled a lot of oil supplies. So that insulates them to some extent.

Avery (14:15.79)
80 to 100 days of consumption. think that that's a nail on the head. mean, this is something that China has been preparing for for decades.

Brandon (14:23.446)
And not only have they moved away from oil for transportation, but for the production of, you know, what we call like petrochemicals, like industrial chemicals, they're now using coal to do that rather than oil. So they're reducing their dependence there for those important, you know, chemicals that we all use.

Avery (14:39.106)
This has been part of President Xi's pursuit of energy autarky, right? The idea that you're going to be able to produce everything you need. And that is possible in terms of electrical generation. It's very hard to do with a globally traded commodity like crude oil, particularly when you have limited production capacity.

Neil (14:56.519)
spell autarky I want to use that at future cocktail party

Avery (15:00.18)
A-U-T-A-R-K-Y. Right there. It's a great word.

Julia (15:02.862)
It's a $10 word. So I want to get further into the EV market impacts that stem from this. But first, let's take another beat because Brandon kind of hit on it here of the other pieces of the energy supply chain more broadly that are also affected by a disruption in the Strait of Hormuz and global shocks to the security system. Safe also tracks critical minerals, aluminum. Take a minute to talk about to what extent those supply chains have also been disrupted and is anything truly safe these days.

Avery (15:29.74)
Yeah, I mean, it's a really important and interesting topic. While oil and gas prices are certainly grabbing national headlines, there are a lot of other supply chains that we are concerned about at SAFE, and we expect policymakers and ultimately consumers are going to be concerned about if this disruption continues. Aluminum is a really interesting part of that conversation. We at SAFE have been raising alarm bells as the US has gone from being a top global producer of aluminum to barely on the map.

We produce less than 20 % of our current demand here domestically. We know this isn't about soda cans. This is about energy technology. This is everything from advanced technologies to transmission lines we use, we need aluminum for. Globally, we've been seeing this picture of declining global supply and increasing demand. So we see, imagine prices would go higher. We are thankfully expecting two new smelters to come online, thanks in part to federal government prioritization of this industrial material. But...

There's risk here where multiple smelters in Bahrain and elsewhere in the Middle East have been hit and the prices have been rising. And we would expect there to be fallout if this conflict continues.

Brandon (16:36.402)
Ammonia, fertilizer, helium. Avery, what do you think the chances are that China invades Taiwan during this period?

Avery (16:39.598)
Absolutely.

Avery (16:45.432)
don't have a good answer on that one. If I did, yeah, if I did, I'd be winning all the polymarket bets. We're certainly raising the concerns around what this means for our relative geopolitical strength when it comes to foreign adversaries and rivals like China. But that's way above my pay grade and read in on intelligence cables for whether that likelihood has gone up or down as a result of this conflict.

Julia (16:47.852)
You'd be winning all the polymarket bets.

Julia (17:11.438)
Well, like you said, there's been a little more muted impact in some ways than what you had forecast back in 2007 and these war games. So maybe we are avoiding some of the brink as some of the worst extremes have not quite played out.

yet. But I do want to underscore that even as we're recording this today, there's a ceasefire, but there have been some missiles lobbed. It's not clear that it will hold and nor do we know exactly how this plane lands. The demands that Iran is making are ones that the US refuses to agree to, like continuing to control the Strait of Hormuz, continuing to enrich uranium. We could be right back here in a matter of days, if not hours. We'll just have to see how this unfolds.

Avery (17:48.238)
Yeah, and we were talking a little bit earlier about the different dynamic that's in play now versus 20 years ago, both in terms of production and in terms of consumption and oil intensity of the U.S. economy. know, I mentioned that $160 was the oil price peak for that 2007 exercise. Just for context, that's $250 a barrel today. So we are not anywhere close to what we had framed that price spike to be in the context of 2007.

doesn't mean it's not still significant, right? We saw WTI prices jump from just under $60 a barrel to end the year to above $110 a barrel yesterday. That's a huge jump, but it's important to put it in the context of what this might have looked like in a previous market dynamic. That's as a result of our having gone from being a net importer to a net exporter, in part because of increased domestic production. And that's something when

SAFE looked at this challenge 20 years ago. had three recommendations for how you think about oil dependence. One is increased supply, produce as much as we can here with the highest possible standards. Second is demand side solutions. So efficiency and alternatives. And three is looking at disruptive technological breakthroughs that can upend the existing market dynamics. And, you know, we've seen some of those play out over the past 20 years, everything from fracking to electrification.

that have really changed a lot of the dynamics around what an oil supply disruption would mean for prices here domestically.

Neil (19:18.318)
So Avery, if we look historically, the growth in the deployment of technologies like solar and wind in the late 70s really emerged as a result of oil shocks and that concern.

Brandon (19:31.52)
And the DOE, Neil. And the DOE. The DOE was created out of it.

Neil (19:34.83)
to be optimistic here, is this potentially an opportunity for electrification, for greater deployment of clean energy resources here domestically in the US and internationally as well? Is this kind of disruption the trigger to potentially get us to a more electrified and cleaner future?

Avery (19:53.464)
There's certainly a historical track record in the US of oil price shocks leading to policy changes. And I think those policy changes have usually been framed in the context of how do we mitigate the impact of these sorts of shocks in the future, whether that's a question of deploying cleaner or more renewable technologies or producing more. And it depends on the flavor of the moment. Our advice would be do both. As you noted,

in the mid 70s with the oil embargo, we saw oil prices surge, we saw lines and rationing, and policymakers responded to consumer frustration and consumer pain with policy action, right? The creation of CAFE standards, the creation of strategic petroleum reserve, right? We took big, bold concrete steps to try to mitigate the sort of risk going forward. In the early 2000s, when we saw

Middle East tensions and again, surging oil prices. We saw President Bush sign the Energy Independence and Security Act, right? Increasing fuel economy standards and including medium and heavy duty vehicles. That was not necessarily because he was looking to drive down emissions, but it was very tied to looking to save the American economy money to make us more competitive. I think there is that opportunity for that conversation right now. We're seeing a lot of national press attention.

We're seeing plenty of policymaker attention and it is absolutely capturing the attention of consumers across the country. One final point I'll note is that in a quick question of what's this going to mean for policymakers here in the U.S. I think it's also important to look at what does this mean for policymakers and governments globally. We are seeing a lot of other countries around the world who are seeing this as a moment to accelerate their transition to becoming an electrostate.

where they can produce the power they need to meet their economic, transportation and other needs domestically, as opposed to relying on global markets.

Brandon (21:45.462)
Neil, what do you think this means for Republicans in Congress and Republican voters? Like, what changes do you think could come out of this?

Neil (21:53.336)
I think right now the focus for Republicans is U.S. military prowess. You're seeing a clear division within the party amongst those who don't like seeing these kinds of foreign interventions, don't like seeing U.S. resources and blood and treasure being expended in the Middle East. The president had promised to get us out of the Middle East, and now we've been kind of sucked back in. But then you have another component within the party who sees the global security, the national security,

importance who have viewed Iran as an enemy since 1979, you know, who have concerns about Iran proclaiming death to America, death to the West, and who see validation in President Trump having the strength to go in there and take this kind of action. You know, my channels were really filled up with folks commending the operation to go in and save our guy who climbed 7,000 feet while injured.

It was such a demonstration of US strength and militaristic power that we went in, we saved our guy. The plane that went in to save him got stuck in the mud. So we sent in another plane and then we blew up the plane and the helicopters that were sent to save him. That's how powerful we are. That we went in, saved our guy and blew up the technology so the Iranians couldn't get a hold of it. There's a lot of people that take great pride in that.

And so I think, Brandon, the Republican response right now is very, very mixed and very, very complicated. Clearly economic concerns, clearly concerns about the U.S. getting entangled in another Middle East quagmire. But there's also a lot of pride in the strength and lethality of the U.S. military. And so I think that's leading to mixed responses amongst Republicans.

Brandon (23:39.948)
Of course, huge pride, but I'm not sure what we've achieved so far in this. How are we better positioned after result of this war? And we're using up a lot of our munitions, right? So if China did want to invade Taiwan, we're less able to provide that response. And two, we're spending a billion dollars a day on this and China spent last year...

$93 billion on its grid. It is going to invest $700 billion into its grid before 2030. They're investing in their economic growth and I'm not sure what we're getting out of this.

Julia (24:17.76)
As like mom in America today, that's one of the biggest concerns is we have this incredible military might and even that is not enough when someone in a speedboat can disrupt huge freight ships moving through the Strait of Hormuz. Like how do you continue to endlessly combat against something as distributed as that type of threat? And as you said, Brandon, we have all these other needs and things that I'm so excited to work on every day, securing our energy supplies, lowering costs for American consumers. And we know that we need a better grid to do a lot of that.

And we, we're not investing in those areas at the same time. Avery, what do you make of this debate of where dollars are going and safe written reports around like the pillars of power and places you see the US needs to invest to compete globally and succeed security wise? What thoughts does this prompt for you?

Avery (25:02.126)
I mean, the US needs people to walk and chew gum at the same time. We need to be able to plan for the future to be competitive in it and not do so in a way that furthers the sort of stranglehold that China has on many of the supply chains that are going be necessary to transition to 21st century. A lot of our work is on critical minerals, both extraction and processing. We do a ton of work on industrial materials as well. I mentioned aluminum, but steel gets included there too. And we have a center for grid security that's very focused on

build out of generation, transmission, cyber-physical security for the grid. This is an increasingly kitchen table topic for Americans, and it's a front burner topic for politicians in Washington. And then we also think through this on the advanced technology side, everything from AI to autonomous vehicles to connected systems to drones, where we know the technologies that are going to define the next hundred years. The challenge we have is that America has not effectively created a pathway to the same extent that China has to be able to be competitive in this.

You know, we're seeing early signs of that progress now. You know, the administration has made some really important steps toward addressing critical minerals in particular, both on the extraction and the processing side. We have lot more work to do if we're going to address this in the same sort of holistic fashion that the CCP has.

Brandon (26:15.298)
about a contrast there. So in 2015, China came up with their Made in China 2025 plan, and they defined EVs as one of their 10 strategic sectors. And so what they've done is every five years, they update their plan. And where we are is cheaper solar leads to cheaper electricity, which makes EVs cheaper, which increases demand for EVs, which increases demand for batteries and makes mineral processing dominance possible.

So they actually have a plan and they stick to it with this like patient, deliberate industrial policy over decades. And we are snapping back and forth. So we had the tax credits for EVs under the inflation reduction act. Trump revoked them. We had the California waiver that allowed California to do its own regulations, which would have required all new purchases to be zero emission vehicles, which would have been a huge accelerant because 10 other states basically adopt that.

So it's like a third of the US auto market would have had this policy accelerant. Avery, where are we on some of those things? Like where are we on the California waiver? I know there's litigation around it. Is it possible to bring that back? And what policies do you see that could be, you know, if there's a change in political control, how do we get back to trying to compete in this fast growing market of EVs, which is rapidly growing around the world, just not here?

Avery (27:33.26)
Yeah and you know i will recycle something that i remember talking about in twenty ten when i was doing interviews triple a on around electrification gas prices and.

consumers respond to financial incentives. We've seen a lot of those financial incentives go away and heavily publicized over the last couple of years. We at SAFE believe that's a real risk because many of those incentives were also tied to domestic sourcing requirements that we think were necessary to drive the sorts of domestic supply chain security investments that this administration is rightly prioritizing. But we're seeing another financial incentive come into play now.

which is high gas prices, right? And we're seeing the early signs, and this would take sustained high prices, I think, for it to really take root, but the early signs of consumer interest in changing their vehicle purchase decisions, at least, when it comes to electric vehicles and hybrid technologies, nobody wants to pay more per mile for how they drive their vehicle. And that pain only gets more abrupt as gas prices surge.

Julia (28:32.366)
I'm always amazed at how much it really does resonate. It's something everyone from your hairdresser to obviously your Uber driver, but it's an everyday conversation and people feel it so immediately. So it has an impact, but I do want to put it in context. know, Edmunds, the car site had said that they saw.

traffic tick up on their website in terms of interest in plugins and hybrid vehicles, but it wasn't like a huge jump. And yes, today's higher oil prices and thus gas prices are prompting more interest. But I always come back to, will this translate to actual purchases? A lot of people get close to pulling the trigger and they don't. know Neil, you actually just bought an EV you said a couple of months ago, or as of last summer, you finally went electric. But I remember it was a bit of a battle for you if I'm remembering correctly. First, Neil, how do you like being an EV driver?

Neil (29:15.064)
I absolutely love it. And I've commented on this program before that I thought one of the big mistakes that the Biden administration made was sort of politicizing EVs because it became this cultural thing to where if you were an EV driver, an EV purchaser, you were perceived to be of the political left. And if you were for a big gasoline fuel truck, you're of the political right.

Brandon (29:37.134)
Wait, Neil, how did he politicize it?

Neil (29:39.982)
I think the administration by emphasizing the credits in the IRA in particular added an element of politics to this. And I've said before, like I think at Ford, F-150 Lightning is like an awesome vehicle that a lot of conservatives ought to embrace, but they didn't want to drive them because they were like, this is a Biden thing. This is a Dem thing. This is a lefty thing. I got to tell you, I got an EV in July. I didn't get an F-150 Lightning. It was a long waiting list, but I love it. The thing drives amazing.

and it's so comfortable and it's so fun to maneuver around in. The challenge I've had quite frankly is, you when I'm in DC, the infrastructure is here. I've got a home charger and I can plug in where I need to. When I travel, it gets much, much more complicated. When I go south of Richmond, there are very few fast chargers available. And in a lot of instances, they're bad.

There's only a couple that you can get to and there'll be people in line and it takes 45 minutes to charge and sometimes the charges are broken or you have to have multiple different apps in order to plug in. There's not like some centralized system and it has led to some frustration and concern, particularly on longer trips. I missed the days of AAA giving me TripTiks that could tell me everywhere I could go. It's a fond memory I had as a kid.

Avery (30:59.01)
They will still do it, I can attest.

Neil (31:02.35)
It's a lot more logistically complicated to plan a trip when you've got to figure out where you're going to plug in your vehicle and how you're going to account for that time. so as someone who is like, I want to be on the record, I love my EV. I'm very bullish on EVs. I don't know that I'll ever go back to a gasoline powered car again. Like I'm into it that much. I want to own EVs for the foreseeable future, but I do have concerns about the viability of our infrastructure here in the country. And again, you know, the Biden administration put a

of money towards getting EV charging stations deployed. And it didn't happen. And I think that more than anything could be the obstacle to greater adoption of EVs. The prices are coming down. The models are really cool and sleek and fun. And there's a bunch of them that I think are appealing to people of all cultural and political ideologies. It's the infrastructure that I feel is what is inhibiting greater deployment of EVs here in the U.S.

Brandon (31:57.908)
Neil, I just want to make a few points there. One, I don't think Biden politicized it by passing a tax credit that made those vehicles cheaper for people and then promoting that. But what you do have is a culture war campaign against EVs that's run by the fossil fuel trade associations like the API.

Julia (32:16.034)
Yeah, I wonder how much is political versus economic competition playing out politically.

Brandon (32:20.628)
and the dealerships, they do not like EVs because like Tesla went direct to consumer and cut them out. And then you have even the UAW, the labor unions are not huge fans of this as well. So you're going up against some very powerful incumbents that have a financial interest in this not happening and are waging that culture war. So we got to up our game on the communications front there.

Julia (32:46.092)
What thoughts are this problem for you, Avery?

Avery (32:47.586)
I think all that's right. think the bottom line though for consumers is like, they don't want to be dragged into a culture war, right? Like they don't want to have to have a national conversation about EV policy. Like they want to figure out how do I get a car that works for me? How do I get power from my house? I I kind of think back to, grew up in Maine and there was a conversation I remember my parents having every summer heading into fall of how are we going to prepare for gas prices heading into winter? And

That came all the way up to do we lock in a price now or do we try to ride it out for the winter and hope that prices come down? The average consumer doesn't want to be in a position of trying to predict where global fuel prices are going to go. And, you know, I will remember the day that my parents ponied up and we lived in a 1700s house and ponied up for an inspection on insulation. And they spent a couple thousand dollars for insulation.

not because they were trying to save the planet, not because they were worried about emissions, but because it was going to cut their fuel costs. They did it. They made a calculus, made the investment, and they watched their fuel prices go down. I think it's a lot of the same calculus across the country when it comes to energy topics. there's this kind of assumption that energy security has to be a national conversation. When in reality, think Americans are used to having an energy security conversation every single day, right? When they fill up their car.

That's about energy security. When their power bill arrives, that's energy security. They understand how this goes and they make decisions based on what will help their own individual energy security. That's why we've seen people on both sides of the political aisle support their individual adoption of solar. They may have divided opinions on national incentives for solar and credits and pro sure, but at end of the day, they're going to make a calculus of

If I put solar panels on my house, I don't have to worry as much about what's going to happen with power prices. If I purchase a more fuel efficient vehicle or electric vehicle, I don't have to worry as much about what's going to happen with the volatility of global oil prices. You know, I think that's a really powerful message that frankly doesn't have much of a political party to it and is really missing from this whole conversation.

Brandon (34:51.775)
One bright spot in this has been that the price of used EVs has come down dramatically.

The average cost of a used EV is like $34,000 now. That's a price point that many Americans can meet. So that's a positive element. The other part, Neil, to your point about charging, that's another area where the Chinese are just beating us. mean, those BYDs, first of all, they go like five, 600 mile range. You don't have this like range anxiety. And second, they can fill them up in five to 10 minutes. So that's a huge edge that we're behind on. That's another place to up our game.

Neil (35:24.598)
I am genuinely convinced, I am convinced that Brandon has a name, image, and likeness deal with the Chinese Communist Party. It's unbelievable.

Julia (35:32.11)
I think even Safe's report chronicle just how many billions of dollars China's put into the EV market.

$30 billion that China put into that sector between 2009, 2023. They went on to sell 11 million EVs in 2024. Avery, I'm cribbing from your own work here. We do have some sense of the scale at which they've been investing and then selling in this area. And as you said, it's not just for funsies. It's a national strategic priority for them. Meanwhile, we've had this stop go over here. And I thought that SAFE does a good job of underscoring the strategic advantage of investing in these sectors. But then you also point out you need the supply.

demand to work together. So if you're going to succeed militarily, you need critical minerals. How do you spur that industry? You need demand signals from

electric vehicles from semiconductor industries, even wind turbines and other sectors. This has to be part of a holistic playbook. And it feels like that's what we're missing is both sides. And that gets into that on the EV side, manufacturing prowess. You mentioned Brandon, EV charging infrastructure, longer ranges. How do we remain competitive on the tip of the spear of where the technology is going? My fear is that we're just asleep at the wheel if you forgive the reference here on too many of those fronts.

Avery (36:44.652)
Yeah, and this is where the Trump administration has been, we believe, very rightly focused on domestic supply chain security, including domestic extraction and processing for critical minerals. And we believe that's a huge, highly vulnerable strategic choke point that could be weaponized against the U.S. and undermines our national security. Where the reality check is coming in as a huge blocker to those projects actually becoming reality, right? Those goals being met is the lack of a demand signal.

Right. And the challenge of off takes, who are those new projects going to sell their products to? If you're doing extraction and mining, who are the processors you're going to sell them to? Well, right now, all those processors are based in China. Okay. So we have to build domestic processing as well. What are those processed products going to be sold to? We have to have industries that are going to be able to enter incentivize to source domestically consume that material.

And we got rid of a huge demand driver, which was the potential growth and the projected growth for the consumer electric vehicle sector. There are other places that can consume parts of that grid storage is certainly on that list. There are a lot of defense and military applications, ones that we've underscored the security risk of not having access to. There are other places you can use batteries, drones being one of them. But at the end of the day, we need a huge demand signal in place in order to create the

pull necessary for the sorts of strategic projects that safe believes need to be built. This administration is very focused on making happen and we need to close that conversation with where does that demand come from and find a way to get to the point where there are sufficient off takes and incentives to support a domestic model for the materials and energy that we're going to need to be competitive going forward.

Neil (38:27.606)
Here's where I put in my plug for FERC Order 2222. Avery, look it up. There's your demand signal.

Julia (38:33.32)
Can't get through an episode without it.

Brandon (38:35.722)
Avery, despite Neil beating me up, I'm only saying things that the CEO of Ford is saying, which is like the Chinese can put American auto industry out of business. You know, they exported 2.6 million cars last year. They're going to get to five to six million cars exports in the next couple of years. But where do you see the technology going? You know, we have Waymo. Everybody loves them. They eat the market wherever they go.

Tesla's basically abandoned mass production of many different models of Teslas. They're basically just making the Model 3 and the Model Y now. And they're really investing in RoboTaxi and the humanoid robots, Optimus. So if this all goes autonomous, what does this just mean for the auto industry generally?

Julia (39:22.092)
fork in the

Julia (39:35.054)
which by the way just happened like out of nowhere and I feel like people like didn't really talk about it. We're like AVs and AVs are coming and then they were like everywhere in LA and I was like cool, cool. Just going to work now, bye.

Avery (39:44.174)
As somebody who went out to the Google facility in 2010, when I first got to AAA and got to ride in the back of what was the chauffeur program at the time, we have been talking about these issues in Washington for a long time. Yeah, there's a belief that these would be highly strategic. Historically, a lot of the innovations that have gone into our military capabilities and civilian capabilities have come out of the auto sector. I believe that will continue and that kind of underscores the imperative nature of U.S. leadership on autonomous vehicles. But it creates an opportunity, right? We have companies that are

global leaders right now for autonomous driving systems. Our challenge now is how do we keep pace with global adversaries who are looking to deploy the same technology, right? There's plenty of Chinese AV companies out there that have made huge gains and are ready to be globally competitive. So how do we look at the Waymos and Zooxes of the world and find ways to understand that their deployment is not just exciting new technology, but that it's a strategic national security imperative.

and it may also help us on the deployment of not just advanced technologies for autonomous driving, but for electrification, right? The bulk of these vehicles are likely to be electric, not because of a mandate, but because they make a whole lot of sense economically when deployed in a sort of ride hailing setting. So I think that's a, to me, a really exciting opportunity, one that's not being covered enough, but is going to require some very intentional policy to make sure that autonomous vehicles don't run into the same.

roadblocks that many other strategic technologies have, which is either the culture wars or, you stop me if you've heard this, local communities pushing back on deployment.

Julia (41:21.326)
Next up, I heard it.

Avery (41:23.658)
I mean, I think that to me is where we still have these concerns, right? There is huge opportunity in front of us, but a very real risk that the U.S. is not going to take advantage of our leadership position.

Neil (41:34.634)
Julia talked about literally being asleep at the wheel. I'm fascinated by autonomous mobility. Loved learning about your background and preparation for this episode. You you were the head of autonomous mobility for INRIX. And you also were on the board of an organization called Culture DC. I live in the DMV area. I'm very curious.

What sort of policy initiatives that you pursued at INRIX? Is there a role for Congress? Like, how did you go about it? And two, as somebody who was on the board of Culture DC, do you think our culture here is ready for autonomous mobility? I'm talking about the DMV region in particular.

Avery (42:11.096)
Two great questions. So on the INRIX front, kind of how does this interface with federal policymakers? One of the biggest drivers and customers for INRIX's software as a service products underpinned by connected vehicle data is federal, state, and local departments of transportation using big data to do a much better job at planning, drive much better outcomes, and manage the road networks in real time. Huge efficiency, potential efficiency gains from that, both efficiency in terms of

time people spend sitting in traffic, as well as the amount of fuel that's ultimately consumed, and frankly, making our roads safer as well. There is an opportunity for policymakers to help to accelerate the deployment of these sorts of virtual infrastructure solutions that leverage big data and AI. We're seeing some early signs of that here in Washington, but we're really seeing that organically accelerate at a pace that I think is really, really exciting for companies like.

INRIX and others who are in that vehicle data and analytics space. And that includes with companies like Waymo and Zoox and others who are leveraging the sorts of physical AI applications. So AI in the real world and turning it into the sort of product that a consumer would demand, which kind of is a good transition into the DMV region. There's a real challenge right now in Washington. mean, Washington DC at the local level, not the federal level around how a company like

Waymo comes to public roads. I view this through a lens of, you know, I'm on a dad's chat from my neighborhood. I also live in Washington and autonomous vehicles are a topic of hot discussion.

Julia (43:47.05)
what are they saying? What are the dads saying?

Avery (43:49.4)
They get a lot of opinions. I would say about a third of them are informed. And more often than not, AVs are being used as a proxy for other frustrations, for a lack of adequate bike and pedestrian infrastructure, for concerns around road safety more generally, for a lack of DC government focus on other issues that are of particular priority. And those are worth understanding.

But at the end of the day, it's not getting to the root question, which is, these vehicles going to help improve the quality of transportation service on our road network? Are they going to provide a safer option for travelers? And are they going to provide a safer experience for pedestrians and bicyclists? So when you get down to that.

Julia (44:32.468)
and solve our energy security challenges by accelerating electrification and lessening dependence on oil markets.

Avery (44:38.882)
Yeah, I tried to inject that one into our chat. That one kind of went over like a lead balloon when we were talking about the competition with China and national security implications of our promise vehicles.

Julia (44:47.886)
I'm trying to imagine you typing that in the chat. Three dots for a long time. was like a...

Brandon (44:52.715)
I did. Yeah. How often does FERC 2222 come up in the dad's chat?

Avery (44:58.574)
It's DC more often than you would think. Oh my god. There are a lot of very informed dads on this group chat with a lot of very strong opinions. But I think it's a really interesting microcosm though of any technology that becomes particularly shiny tends to be used as a foil for whatever anyone's frustrated about.

And I think the reality is there's very little question that autonomous vehicles are going to improve the quality of service across our roadways. It's going to make our roadways safer. And ultimately, done at scale, it's going to allow the US to be more competitive. It's a huge win-win situation. I think the biggest roadblock is going to be not getting sucked down in the same Charybdis of NIMBYism that too many other technologies have been of late.

Julia (45:43.778)
Charybdis? How do you spell that one?

Avery (45:46.131)
Charybdis, a character from the upcoming hit movie, The Odyssey. It's a massive whirlpool monster that sucks everything down to the bottom of the ocean.

Julia (45:54.36)
Noted!

Well, it was funny here in LA. actually like Waymo a lot, use it often. It's a car city here. So getting from A to B with ease in a vehicle is actually like a great unlock. Although it was pretty funny because sometimes they do get stuck, right? And they got stuck in the Venice canals and it turned into this party. It's like everyone came out and they were like drinking and they're like in this moment of great division. The one thing that unites us is the stalled Waymo and like everyone was partying and like cheering when it started to finally move hours later. So not only do AV solve all these other problems they bring us

together.

Avery (46:26.176)
I will say there's also a huge difference in positioning for people who've actually been in an autonomous vehicle versus haven't. Those who've been in it are like, this is great. I want it for me and my kids. Those who haven't still have questions.

Julia (46:39.138)
It's a little bit tricky if the door doesn't close, it gets stuck. can't do everything on its own. But I'm glad we went there on autonomous vehicles, because as we said, there's a lot of like pieces to this puzzle. And that could be this demand driver that then feeds into all these other supply chain questions we have and even energy security questions we have. But I do think the rubber hits the road. Gosh, there's so many terms you can use when you talk about driving and it's hard not to overuse them. So bear with me, everyone. This really comes together.

In the manufacturing sector for EVs in my mind, because you have technological innovation, have supply chains, you have the consumer demand feeding into energy security discussions, not only in terms of technological development, but then obviously diversifying our energy sources. And there was this pretty bold headline the Wall Street Journal put out recently saying, America now has an EV rust belt, high gas prices won't rescue it.

So here we are talking about the conflict in the Middle East, consumer interest ticking up in light of these higher gas prices, but it comes back to like, will anything actually change because of this moment in time? like specifically on that Avery, do you see consumers turning to EVs more in a real way this year, 2026, as a result of the Middle East conflict, but then more broadly, can the automakers wait for that uptick? If we're seeing a rust belt now, or these million square feet facilities are sitting idle, so much money invested because the demand isn't there. Do we just end up back at square one?

just has me really concerned about, you know, the start-stop nature of all this and in a very real way where you have people now losing jobs and losing momentum in that sector more broadly.

Avery (48:06.254)
So I think the shift in consumer behavior is still a huge TBD. We are a month into this conflict. As you mentioned, we have seen some early signs of Google searches or Edmunds searches for electric vehicles rising. We've seen some early signs for some first couple of months of 2026 electric vehicle sales being a little bit higher. As we talked about earlier, the purchase price disparity for an

ICE vehicle, internal combustion engine vehicle versus an electric, used electric vehicle coming closer to some price parity, about a $1,300 difference. But this is really going to depend on how long this price spike lasts and ultimately how long it sticks in the memory of consumers. I, I think there is, you know, there's a lot of reason to expect that price impact, whether or not the conflict continues, but the price impact is going to continue for a while longer.

And then I think the question then becomes, what does it do in terms of demand from consumers, both demand in their vehicle purchases and demand on their policymakers of what do they expect for action to prevent this from happening?

Julia (49:05.088)
again. wonder if people close to the industry will feel disillusioned though if they were all excited about an EV plant say moving to their neighborhood in a cornfield in Michigan like this Magna plant. It's a supplier to GM and that's the one that's profiled in this Wall Street Journal piece that's now effectively closing up shop and it could leave a bad taste in people's mouths that this is a flighty industry. That's potentially a concern.

Avery (49:27.0)
Yeah, absolutely. And I think hearing from automakers, was at CERAWeek two weeks ago in Houston and heard Ford CEO Jim Farley talking about this. Auto executives still view this as it's not a matter of if it's a matter of when and how fast we're going to see growth in market share for electric vehicles. And that's the same thing you hear around the world. The question that we have seen post

you know, a of the, the administrative and legislative moves over the past year is an expectation and the data has borne it out that vehicle sales, the trajectory is going to be bent downward. And now the question is how much is this recent price disruption going to lead to that trajectory being bent back up at the end of the day, automakers are going to build and sell vehicles that consumers demand. And there's a very real chance that this is a consumer demand moment that might change consumer behavior, but.

It's still too soon to tell.

Julia (50:19.414)
It feels like this is a very poignant moment for energy. And in some ways it really feels like it's coming to a precipice because of these other geopolitical shifts and technological shifts and now an act of conflict. When you think about these forces at play, what's safe sort of theory of the case of what the United States needs to do right now to sort of win on all these fronts?

Avery (50:36.398)
You've really hit on it. We have seen over the past 20 years that the number of black swan, of generational once in a lifetime sorts of events are really coming more frequently. At least have a couple a year. And what we really need is a near and a long-term strategy to de-leverage our adversaries, increase our capabilities, including power generation, and be prepared for worst case scenarios when it comes to supply chain disruptions.

Julia (51:02.196)
mention, we also have more frequent disasters, natural disasters, you know, everything from flooding to fires and heat waves and beyond. So that adds yet another element that we have to be prepared for, even if you don't consider the environmental climate action side of it purely from a military perspective or, gosh, a health and human safety perspective. I think we're learning that we have to be so much more proactive on a bunch of different fronts in a way we didn't have to be in the past.

Avery (51:27.062)
Yeah, whether it's the electrical grid or oil extraction or processing or refining, what we watch, both coordinated events as well as natural disasters, knockout capacity, that puts a tremendous strain on our energy systems. And we believe we need a real pathway that prepares us to deal with those sorts of disruptions in a way that ensures that American businesses and American consumers can have stability when it comes to the energy they need to lead their lives. What's interesting now is like

the amount of stakeholders who are coming to the table recognizing that energy security is having a moment, right, is a a critical topic for us to get right as a country. And good news is there are a lot of people right now, policymakers, companies, stakeholders who care about energy security. They all care about it for very different reasons. And they all have different components of energy security that they want to prioritize. know, SAFE's challenge is how do we...

gather this focus, gather this support and translate it into a roadmap that is durable and positions us in a way that we're going to compete globally and win globally while addressing the sorts of supply chain security that we believe really undercuts our ability to compete, be secure as a nation.

Julia (52:44.076)
We're durable, I think is so key because we've learned that as a nation, we cannot flip-flop on our policies or we lack the ability to execute because these are energy projects that take a long time to deploy. They can be disrupted easily. We need to have a strategy to combat that volatility.

Avery (52:57.006)
Yeah. And I think we talked about it before the recording started, but like I mentioned that you and I many, many, many moons ago had done that improv class together. To me, is like energy security now is becoming a, needs to become a yes and conversation, which is like in improv, how you transition, right? You're only ever supposed to say yes and to what somebody tells you. And we really need to take that same approach to thinking about policy of is this a challenge of bringing more power onto the grid? Yes. And this is a problem about transmission.

Yes, and this is a problem about secure supply chains. Yes, and this is a problem about critical minerals and finding a way to continue to bring these sorts of this multitude of different challenges and positions into one roadmap that require you have to solve this problem holistically. If you just solve one piece of it, you're not going to actually improve the outcome. So how do we take something very complex and bring together the stakeholders necessary to drive sound policy decisions?

Julia (53:52.558)
I love that we learned something from that improv class of a decade plus ago. I just hope that we don't keep improving through our energy policy because that's a little bit

Avery (53:59.544)
Yes, I am. That is true. I'd love for this to be more of a scripted show, ideally not a scripted drama.

Julia (54:05.314)
Yeah, exactly. Well, Avery, thanks so much for coming on the show to close us out here. Any final thoughts or things you want to leave us with?

Avery (54:13.006)
Yeah, I've really enjoyed being here for this conversation today. SAFE does have one very exciting.

upcoming. We're hosting our annual Safe Summit in Washington DC on April 27th and 28th. This really is a two-day festival bringing together a lot of the same conversations you've heard here today around energy security, power generation, winning the AI race, supply chain security, the intersection of energy and military conversations. So we'd love to have any of your listeners join us. It's going to be a great conversation.

really valuable time to interface with policymakers, decision makers, and companies that are doing exciting work in this space.

Julia (54:51.758)
Thank you, Avery, for helping us navigate all these forces at play here. Appreciate your insights and look forward to waving to you from a waymo sometime soon.

Avery (55:00.27)
Yeah, absolutely, Julia. Thank you guys for having me.

Julia (55:05.87)
Well, that's our episode for this week. As always, please make sure to like, follow and subscribe to Political Climate on your favorite podcast app and social media platforms. It's the best way to hear about new episodes and the things we might be up to. Also, head on over to politicalclimatepodcast.com to check out the website and sign up for our soon returning newsletter. Political Climate is brought to you by ClearPath, one of the most influential organizations working to advance American energy innovation while reducing global emissions.

on Apple podcasts, Spotify, and beyond. We're on X @Poli_Climate and on LinkedIn at political climate. I'm Julia Pyper, your host. Bruno Falcon is our wonderful producer. Thanks so much for listening.